The rapid expansion of self-checkout technology has fundamentally transformed the retail landscape, with clear evidence showing both job displacement and workforce evolution. While self-checkout systems have eliminated approximately 300,000 cashier positions since 2019, they’ve also created new roles and driven wage increases for remaining positions
Table of Contents
The debate over self-checkout’s impact on employment isn’t simply about job elimination—it’s about workforce transformation. As retailers increasingly adopt automated systems, the traditional cashier role is evolving into new positions that require different skill sets and often command higher wages.
The Current State of Self-Checkout Technology
Self-checkout systems have experienced explosive growth, with the global market projected to reach $17.28 billion by 2032, representing a compound annual growth rate of 15.5%. In the United States alone, the market is valued at $1.91 billion in 2024, with an expected 12% annual growth rate through 2030.
This technological expansion has been driven by several factors:
- Operational efficiency: Retailers can process more transactions with fewer staff members
- Cost reduction: Self-checkout enables significant labor cost savings
- Pandemic acceleration: Health concerns boosted contactless shopping preferences
Currently, 58% of grocery stores have implemented self-checkout systems, with major retailers like Walmart, Target, and Amazon leading the adoption. However, the technology’s implementation hasn’t been without challenges, leading some retailers to reconsider their strategies.
Employment Impact: The Numbers Tell the Story
Cashier Job Decline
The most direct impact of self-checkout technology has been on cashier positions. According to multiple data sources, the employment picture is clear:
Historical Job Losses:
- Cashier employment declined from 3.6 million to 3.3 million positions between 2019-2023
- This represents a loss of approximately 300,000 jobs in just four years
- The Bureau of Labor Statistics projects an additional 11% decline in cashier employment from 2023-2033
Projected Future Impact:
- Multiple studies predict 6-7.5 million retail jobs are at risk of automation
- Retail cashier positions face the highest risk of automation displacement
- The projected cashier job growth rate is -10% from 2018-2028
Wage Paradox: Higher Pay for Fewer Jobs
Despite employment declining, wages for remaining cashier positions have increased dramatically:
- Mean annual wages rose from $24,370 in 2019 to $30,710 in 2023
- This represents a 26% increase in compensation
- Cashier salaries have increased 24% over the last five years
This wage growth suggests that remaining cashier positions require higher skills or that labor market dynamics have driven compensation upward as positions become scarcer.
Major Retailer Experiences and Strategy Shifts
Retailers Pulling Back from Self-Checkout
Several major retailers have modified or reversed their self-checkout strategies due to real-world challenges:
Walmart: Removed self-checkout machines from multiple locations after receiving negative feedback and experiencing operational issues.
Target: Limited self-checkout to customers with 10 items or fewer, citing the need to improve the shopping experience and address theft concerns.
Dollar General: Eliminated self-checkout from approximately 12,000 locations due to theft and customer service issues.
Five Below: Removing self-checkout entirely from “highest-risk” locations, with CEO Joel Anderson identifying self-checkout replacement as the most effective theft mitigation strategy.
Success Stories: When Self-Checkout Works
McDonald’s: Represents a positive example, with self-service kiosks increasing sales by 11% while enabling workforce redeployment rather than reduction.The company reassigns former cashiers to customer service roles and kitchen positions.
Costco: CEO Ron Vachris reported that “Scan & Go” tests have been “extremely successful” in moving customers through lines efficiently.
The Theft Problem: A Major Implementation Challenge
One of the most significant issues undermining self-checkout effectiveness is theft and shrinkage:
Theft Statistics:
- 15% of self-checkout users have purposely stolen items.
- 44% of those thieves plan to steal again.
- Self-checkout systems have shrinkage rates of 3.5-4% compared to less than 1% for traditional cashiers.
Industry Response:
- The National Retail Federation reported a 93% increase in average shoplifting incidents in 2023 versus 2019.
- Two-thirds of retailers surveyed believe self-checkout losses are becoming a bigger problem.
- Some retailers are investing heavily in AI-powered theft detection systems.
The Economics of “So-So Automation”
MIT economist Daron Acemoglu has identified self-checkout as “so-so automation”—technology that displaces workers without generating significant productivity gains. This research reveals a critical flaw in many self-checkout implementations:
Productivity Challenges:
- Self-checkout often makes shopping slower and more error-prone
- Technical failures require human intervention, limiting efficiency gains
- Increased theft and errors undermine economic benefits
- One self-checkout station can theoretically handle the work of 2-3 traditional cashiers, but real-world performance often falls short
Demographic Impact: Who Gets Hurt Most?
The impact of self-checkout technology falls disproportionately on certain groups:
Gender Impact:
- Women comprise 73% of cashier positions, making them the most affected demographic.
- This gender disparity amplifies the social impact of automation.
Age Considerations:
- Young workers traditionally relied on cashier positions for entry-level employment
- Older workers face greater challenges adapting to self-checkout technology
- Elderly shoppers tend to dislike self-checkout systems
Economic Vulnerability:
- 36% of retail workers currently receive some form of public assistance
- The average retail worker is 38 years old, contradicting perceptions about young, part-time workers.
- 71% of retail workers are full-time employees
Labor Union Response and Policy Initiatives
Union Opposition
The United Food and Commercial Workers (UFCW) union has mounted the strongest opposition to self-checkout expansion:
Key Arguments:
- Self-checkout is designed to “drastically cut staffing and reduce labor costs”
- The technology particularly threatens women and minorities
- Human cashiers provide superior customer service and disability support
Action Strategies:
- Consumer education campaigns encouraging shoppers to choose human cashiers
- Legislative advocacy supporting bills that regulate self-checkout implementation
- Collective bargaining to negotiate technology deployment clauses
Legislative Responses
Several states have proposed or enacted legislation to regulate self-checkout:
California’s SB 1446: Would require safe staffing levels and regulate self-checkout deployment, ensuring worker input in technology decisions
Oregon’s AFL-CIO: Proposed limiting grocery stores to no more than two self-checkout kiosks per location.
The Future of Retail Employment
Technology Evolution
The future effectiveness of self-checkout depends on overcoming current limitations:
AI Integration: Advanced artificial intelligence could reduce error rates and improve user experience, making self-checkout more viable
Hybrid Models: Combining self-checkout with human oversight may optimize both efficiency and customer service
Mobile Solutions: Smartphone-based scanning and payment systems may replace traditional self-checkout kiosks
Employment Transformation Scenarios
Pessimistic Scenario: Continued technological improvement could lead to 6-7.5 million retail jobs at risk by 2030.
Moderate Scenario: Self-checkout adoption stabilizes at current levels, with labor redeployment offsetting direct job losses.
Optimistic Scenario: Technical limitations and consumer preferences limit self-checkout expansion, preserving traditional cashier positions while creating new roles.
New Job Categories Emerging
As traditional cashier roles disappear, new positions are being created:
Self-Checkout Attendants: Providing customer support and monitoring transactions.
Customer Experience Specialists: Focused on enhancing the overall shopping experience.
Retail Technology Support Staff: Maintaining and troubleshooting self-checkout systems.
Consumer Attitudes and Preferences
Recent surveys reveal divided consumer preferences:
Pro-Self-Checkout:
- 65% of shoppers prefer self-checkout for purchases of 10 items or less
- 80% of millennials and Gen Z favor self-checkout options
- Primary reasons: speed, control, and shorter lines
Traditional Checkout Preference:
- 40% of Baby Boomers still prefer human cashiers
- Valued factors: human interaction, assistance with complex purchases
- Concerns about technology reliability and theft prevention
Industry-Wide Automation Trends
Self-checkout is part of a broader automation trend affecting retail:
Broader Automation Impact:
- 24.9% of current retail jobs are likely to be automated by 2027
- 2.1 million retail jobs in the UK have a “high chance” of automation
- Automation extends beyond checkout to inventory management, customer service, and supply chain operations
Economic Benefits:
- Estimated $15.3 billion productivity boost to the retail sector from automation
- Creation of approximately 464,700 new tech roles over the next four years
Global Perspectives and Regional Variations
International Adoption:
- Self-checkout adoption varies significantly by region
- Grocery stores show the highest adoption rates globally
- European retailers have been more cautious due to stronger labor protections
- Asian markets show rapid adoption, particularly in urban areas
Regional Implementation Differences:
- Urban areas see higher self-checkout adoption rates
- Rural locations maintain more traditional staffing models
- Store format significantly influences implementation strategy
Best Practices for Successful Implementation
Retailers finding success with self-checkout follow several key principles:
Customer-Centric Design:
- Clear signage and intuitive interfaces minimize customer confusion
- Item limits help manage customer expectations and reduce errors
- Hybrid staffing models maintain human support when needed
Technology Integration:
- Advanced AI and computer vision reduce theft and errors
- Mobile payment integration streamlines the checkout process
- Real-time inventory tracking improves accuracy and customer satisfaction
Workforce Redeployment:
- Retraining programs help displaced workers transition to new roles
- Skills development initiatives prepare workers for technology-enhanced positions
- Career pathway planning provides long-term employment security
The Bottom Line: Transformation, Not Elimination
The evidence clearly shows that self-checkout technology does displace traditional cashier positions. The 300,000 job decline from 2019-2023 and projected continued losses make this undeniable. However, the full story is more nuanced than simple job elimination.
Key Findings:
- Job displacement is real but accompanied by wage increases for remaining positions
- Retailer experiences vary widely, with some pulling back from self-checkout due to operational challenges
- New job categories are emerging as the workforce adapts to technological change
- Consumer preferences remain divided, suggesting continued demand for human cashiers
Success Factors:
- Technical reliability and theft prevention effectiveness
- Retailer commitment to workforce redeployment and retraining
- Consumer acceptance and seamless user experience
- Supportive policy environment that balances innovation with worker protection
Rather than inevitable mass unemployment, self-checkout represents a workforce transformation that requires proactive management from retailers, policymakers, and workers themselves. The ongoing retreat of some major retailers from self-checkout suggests that the technology’s job displacement effects may be more limited than initially feared.
The future of retail employment will likely involve a hybrid model combining automated systems with human expertise, creating opportunities for workers who can adapt to new technologies while maintaining the personal service that many customers still value. Success in this transformation depends on ensuring that technological progress serves both economic efficiency and social welfare.
The retail industry’s experience with self-checkout offers valuable lessons for managing automation in other sectors: technology adoption must be balanced with workforce development, customer needs, and operational realities to achieve sustainable success.